You are here: Home » Song reviews » Readers Write In #280: Guide evaluation of Svetlana Alexievich’s Second Hand Time (2013)

Readers Write In #280: Guide evaluation of Svetlana Alexievich’s Second Hand Time (2013)

(by G Waugh)

You’re a girl with two youngsters. You personal a Masters diploma and work as a professor in some college. You had free training, free medical amenities and so do your youngsters. Your husband works as an engineer in some State-owned firm. You reside in a modest house and since there isn’t a ‘market’ on the market, you’re a bit anxious that you simply don’t get to personal quite a lot of shopper durables. There is just one ‘model’ of cleaning soap, one type of tv which telecasts solely State-censored content material and other than studying books, you aren’t entitled to any type of leisure. You make use of the massive quantity of spare time to have interaction along with your neighbours and reside with them peacefully. Your neighbours are multi-ethnic and you can’t observe any type of discrimination with them since they’re formally forbidden and likewise as a result of you don’t have any cause to. For no matter you’re given by the State, you’re simply anticipated to stay loyal to it and are forbidden to speak in opposition to it in public boards.

You’ve got grown in an atmosphere like this proper out of your childhood. Your dad and mom too had lived lives that have been much more Spartan and all of them needed to endure wars, famines, illness and focus camps. However a lot of them, regardless of struggling a lot within the fingers of the State have been loyal to it, could also be as a result of the State propaganda was too robust or they believed genuinely in what they have been doing or the logic behind the propaganda was a bit too strong or a mix of all of those. They’d instilled the identical spirit of ‘patriotism’ in you no matter which means and you’ve got accepted state authoritarianism as an immutable facet of your life, similar to some folks settle for the burdens of casteism or race and attempt to reside with it. However regardless of all of the respect you might have in the direction of your nation and the State, you secretly, generally lengthy for a greater life with barely higher requirements of residing the place you may select your favorite model of cleaning soap from many, you may decide your favorite style from a curated checklist of films, you may come out and categorical your self in opposition to the federal government and take part within the technique of decision-making. However that’s that. All of your ambitions are simply too modest and you’re fortunately conscious that you’re residing in the one nation on the planet that has zero unemployment, free training, healthcare and low-cost housing. You don’t need to lose the perks that you’ve got at present and sooner or later, when somebody comes and tells you that you could retain all of this stuff and but hope for a greater residing, it’s pure that you’re seduced by the concept.

Quickly the concept captivates folks round you and quite a lot of your neighbours begin speaking in opposition to the federal government immediately. There’s immediately no worry of retribution and also you begin becoming a member of protests that demand civil rights akin to democracy, free press, and so forth. and likewise a little bit of market-oriented socialism. Those that lead these protests seem as heroes to you who maintain promising that they too are full-blooded socialists who vouch for all of the State-sponsored privileges that you simply get pleasure from presently and their solely mission is to barely alter the character of the State for the higher. In any case, the founding fathers of your State additionally needed their successor- generations to get pleasure from higher lives that have been based mostly on freedom, equality and dignity.

However sooner or later, immediately you’re informed that you simply now not are employed at your college whose possession has modified in a single day. Your engineer husband has been laid off since his firm is now not owned by the State. The financial savings you might have at your financial institution are price no more than a loaf of bread, the training your youngsters have, shall be charged based mostly on ‘market’ guidelines and the hospitals in your block are now not free. However you’re given one huge privilege that you’ve got been denied all these years- freedom. You may speak in opposition to the federal government, you can begin a enterprise by yourself, repair costs on your items, be taught expertise that you simply need to and make a profession out of them, purchase items, hoard them and promote them at increased costs, bid for pure sources of your nation and in case you are highly effective or manipulative, purchase a lion’s share of them and make a killing out of it. Inside months, you see supermarkets with merchandise of various manufacturers and varieties lined up in neatly-stacked cabinets arising in your city, you see colourful ads in your low cost tv promoting merchandise that you simply have been secretly dreaming of all lately and movies and exhibits that you simply have been by no means allowed to observe are proper there in entrance of you on your taking.

However you quickly realise that this isn’t what you needed, you inform your folks that one thing has been terribly misunderstood on the prime of the management solely to grasp that every one your folks too have been affected by the identical, unexpected malaise which has struck them out of the blue. Quickly it’s revealed that the leaders of the rebel who spoke in opposition to the State have ascended to the highest and are busy promoting the State-owned firms and large pure sources to associates and family members getting huge kickbacks in return and when it’s revealed that that is what they’d planning proper from the primary, you’re merely shocked. However inside months, you realise that it’s all too late and you’re compelled like thousands and thousands of your compatriots to neglect what you had up to now and be taught fully new methods so as to survive. You progress from one metropolis to a different for a dignified job, you get nothing and so that you determine to scrub automobiles or do some menial jobs. You quickly search the assistance from one of many branches of a newly-created Mafia to get a correct job. The Mafia says that your Masters diploma and your husband’s engineering qualification are simply shit since 1000’s and 1000’s of day by day wage labourers who do menial duties at the moment possess the identical or increased educational {qualifications}.

You once more migrate to another nation within the former Union you lived, work for greater than twelve hours a day alongside along with your youngsters solely to earn a day’s meal. Your husband you realise, is steadily dropping his thoughts getting hooked on booze and medicines unable to bear the shock of the household’s immediately shifted fortunes. You might be left to fend for your loved ones alone however the nation the place you’re employed is immediately torn with ethnic strife and tensions. Individuals who don’t belong there are discriminated, generally hounded, raped and killed. The nation which earlier than the rebel was a part of the erstwhile State-controlled Empire and whose residents whom you knew too properly as both your pleasant neighbours or colleagues, has became a hotbed of ethnic nationalism, ejecting foreigners like a feverish physique that has encountered a pernicious microbe. You and your loved ones are compelled to reside in hiding as the brand new rulers have referred to as for an ethnic cleaning and information about pogroms and large-scale killings abound in all places. All of your concepts about higher lives and dignity that you simply harboured a few years in the past have disappeared out of your thoughts and what stays inside your head is one huge wounded, animal that’s cornered and besieged on all sides that will cease at nothing so as to add another minute to its life. The native nationalist hooligans supported by the native military knock each house in search of out foreigners and the second they meet any of them, they ensure they’re brutalized or killed ruthlessly. One night, you hear a knock on the door of the deserted home into whose closet you’re hiding for weeks and shortly the mob breaks in. They rapidly find the closet, open it and ensure your identification. You beg and plead them to spare your youngsters not less than however they first assault your husband and mutilate his limbs, permitting him to bleed to dying. They flip in the direction of your youngsters however you already are in your knees begging them to cease.


If the above story seems to be like one from a Mani Ratnam movie made within the 1990s, it isn’t your fault. Once I was studying Svetlana Alexevitch’s Second Hand Time, I felt like I used to be seeing a well-made, political Mani Ratnam movie. In 2015, Svetlana grew to become the primary journalist to win the Nobel Prize for Literature for her works in non-fiction. Second-Hand Time, just like a lot of her works on Soviet Historical past is an oral recounting of experiences of Russians and erstwhile Soviet residents who underwent a searing, blood spattered transition from socialism to market financial system. The above story is so typical of thousands and thousands of educated ladies who had lived dignified lives underneath the Soviet system and who, on account of a sudden change within the management, misplaced every little thing that they’d cherished and valued and ended up turning into slaves or wage-labourers and even prostitutes.

The sweeping, 496-page account of Svetlana deserves consideration on account of quite a lot of components. First, it isn’t a historical past e-book within the standard sense, about rulers and armed forces generals taking up a rustic or tales about financial progress and falling indices of wealth distribution and GDP. As Svetlana says, her work is an try to seize the political historical past of a rustic from the angle of its residents, a observe that also has not come into vogue, regardless of quite a few avenues which have emerged within the wake of proliferation of social media platforms that present a channel for particular person expression. The e-book because of this, doesn’t attempt to give a third-person or a chicken’s eye-view account of the occasions and by confining itself to particular person voices that narrate their very own private tales, it broadens its scope to cowl quite a lot of dimensions which can be often missed out in conventionally-styled narratives of historical past. It’s for this facet that efficiently finds a center floor between fictional tales and non-fiction narratives that the e-book received her the world’s highest literary award in 2015.

However as a Marxist sympathizer, I discovered the story intriguing on some extra facets. First, the e-book shatters to smithereens the commonly-held Western notions about Russians and their political inclinations and selections. At any time when I see Hollywood movies or learn accounts of Russia by Western journalists, I by no means had been in a position to miss a tone of derision or condescension that mocks the attitudes of Russian commoners for both supporting an authoritarian type of authorities or selecting to reside underneath one. Russians are usually proven both to be fools or innocents who on account of their lack of publicity to exterior world reside underneath a regime run by autocrats and self-serving politicians. Svetlana’s account that incorporates testimonies from folks over the size and breadth of the previous Soviet Union, not directly questions this doubtful assumption. The historical past and tradition of Russians which have historically been extra allied with these of Asians than Europeans are way more complicated and multi-layered to be understood simply by means of a simplistic Western lens. Russians, in keeping with Svetlana’s e-book, whole-heartedly supported the Socialist Revolution that occurred underneath Lenin in 1917, fought to safeguard the brand new institution by means of the West-sponsored civil wars for 4 years till 1922, suffered coercion and focus camps underneath Stalin, generally willingly and generally half-heartedly till the ruthless Nazi invasion in 1942, gave their lives in thousands and thousands willingly to decimate the Axis powers in 1945, labored onerous as soon as once more to rebuild their Empire publish the Conflict, drew nice delight once they despatched the primary man to Area underneath Khrushchev and lived peacefully with totally different races and communities belonging to fifteen totally different international locations having fun with full employment, free, common training and healthcare for over fifty years. Should you assume Svetlana by supporting the Soviets seems to be one more Marxist propagandist, it’s time you learn this e-book to get a grip on the ugly sufferings endured by harmless Soviet residents within the focus camps created in the course of the Stalin period. Svetlana’s different books too, present related accounts on the atrocities dedicated by the Soviet State particularly in the course of the Chernobyl catastrophe of 1987 which went on to grow to be the premise for the latest, universally acclaimed TV collection, Chernobyl directed by Johan Renck.

Earlier than I end the essay, there are only some vital questions that I wish to elevate. What occurred within the Soviet Union on the eve of its dismantling in 1991 and the next years previous the brand new millennium, is one huge, ugly tragedy whose scale approaches the horrors, a smaller nation like India endured throughout its partition in 1947. However why wasn’t this story not documented sufficient and never given due consideration by journalists and the so-called free press that the Western a part of the world is so pleased with? If I accuse them of being ‘deliberately blind’ to those horrors and attribute this to their biases which can be rooted within the free-market ideology whose failures might now not be hidden within the erstwhile Soviet Union, will they’ve something to provide me in reply? When the West was supporting the brand new President of Russia, the corrupt Boris Yeltsin with trillions of {dollars} to control public opinion and elections in 1995 that have been getting in favour of the Communist Occasion, what have been the Western newsmakers, the self-appointed custodians of democracy and common freedom busying themselves with?

Russians who have been born within the capitalist period of Russia and had no private experiences of residing underneath a socialist regime, in keeping with the logic of the West, have to be discovering it simpler to undertake themselves to a supposedly, merit-based, free-market system that provides alternatives for everybody to develop. However why are 1000’s of them sporting T-shirts with Stalin’s faces on them, attending conferences that debate Marxism and Soviet life and deeply want for a return to the socialist system? When ethnic conflicts such because the Chechenyan disaster and the Azerbaijan-Armenian problem come to the floor as they do at the moment, doesn’t the West know very properly that these points had no place to exist when the Soviet Union was in place? Why don’t they’ve the heart to say it even as soon as when they’re writing pages and pages about these points at the moment? Neglect me. I’m a Marxist sympathizer and all I say might be interpreted solely as socialist propaganda. What solutions have they got when one fashionable Russian born and introduced up underneath the Yeltsin-Putin period, asks his father in Svetlana’s e-book, “You have been poor once you have been underneath the socialist system, I perceive. However why didn’t you get wealthy post-1991 when it was really easy?”

Supply hyperlink

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *